Presnell Produce and More

Feeding our Community One Bite at a Time

Tasty Amish Products

Amish Butter, Cheese, Cookies & Fried Pies

Stop by Presnell’s Produce & More on scenic Highway 209 in Clyde and stock up on real Amish products. We carry hand-rolled Amish butter, buttermilk, cheese, fried pies, cookies, peanut butter, snacks, and more.

Hand-rolled Amish butter. Made the old way.

If you haven’t tried real Amish butter yet, now’s the time. This is the good stuff (the best kind of butter!), hand-rolled and made the old-fashioned way.

Amish butter makers start with fresh cream from pasture-raised cows, then slowly churn it by hand or with simple machinery.

The result is richer, creamier butter with a higher butterfat content (around 85% or more) than what you’ll find in most grocery stores. Amish-produced butter is pure and flavorful. It makes everything taste so much better. We keep both ½-pound and 2-pound rolls in stock.

Quality amish products are available at reasonable prices!

Visit us today!

Bought a homemade fried apple pie. WOW!! tasted heavenly. “

Yolanda Ferguson

Amish buttermilk

Alongside the butter, we also carry traditional Amish buttermilk. It’s the real byproduct of churning—thicker and more tangy than the cultured versions on supermarket shelves. Great for biscuits, pancakes, cornbread, and anything else that needs a little extra flavor.

Looking for milk too?

While you’re here for the Amish butter and buttermilk, pick up a jug of Kreider Farms milk. It’s not Amish. Kreider’s a fourth-generation family dairy in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania. Kreider Farms milk is the same kind of real, farm-fresh milk we like to carry. Creamy, simple ingredients, and a taste that reminds people of the milk they grew up with. Visit our dairy products page

Cheese, snacks & more

We also bring in a solid selection of Amish products from Walnut Creek, Ohio, including:

  • Amish cheeses (Sharp Cheddar, Colby, and others)
  • Walnut Creek snacks and popcorn
  • Amish peanut butter
  • Cookies
  • Homemade fried pies (these sell fast—ask what’s available today)
  • Certain breads

Why Amish products taste different

Amish communities still rely on traditional methods passed down through generations. Less processing and more care usually means better flavor. Whether you’re spreading Amish butter on toast, baking with the buttermilk, or grabbing a fried pie for the road, you’re getting something made the old way.

Come see us

We’re right here on Highway 209 in Upper Crabtree. While you’re picking up Amish butter, snacks, and a jug of Kreider Farms milk, you can also grab our farm-raised local beef (we’ve been raising cattle here for over 25 years), fresh produce, and other local goods.

Have questions? Just call us at 828-627-0440 or stop in. We’re happy to help you find what you need.