Hey Everyone, Get Your Local Amish Butter at Presnell’s

Come on by Presnells, your local farm store on the scenic Highway 209.

We offer a wide variety of Amish products, including butter, buttermilk, cheese, popcorn, snacks, FRIED PIES, crafts, and more. 

By the way, if you have not tried Amish butter before, now would be the perfect time!

The Art of Making Old-Fashioned, Hand-Rolled Amish Butter

When it comes to hand-rolled butter, the Amish employ time-honored techniques that yield a product distinctly different from commercial varieties. 

Starting with fresh, raw milk from their pasture-raised cows, Amish butter makers separate the cream and churn it slowly by hand or with simple, horse-powered machinery. 

This process results in butter that is rich, creamy, and bursting with flavor.

What makes Amish butter special?

• High butterfat content: Amish butter typically boasts a higher butterfat content (around 85% or more) compared to commercial butter. This richness contributes to its exceptional texture and flavor.
  
  
• Natural ingredients: Unlike commercial butter, which may contain preservatives or colorings, Amish butter is usually made from raw or lightly pasteurized cream. This minimal processing allows the natural flavors to shine through.
  
  
• Slow churn makes it so GOOD! The Amish’s commitment to butter-making techniques ensures that their butter is rich with superior flavor and texture.

You’ll love Amish buttermilk too

Besides Amish hand-rolled butter logs, we also offer Amish buttermilk.

Made as a byproduct of churning butter, Amish buttermilk is rich, tangy, and full of flavor. 

Unlike the cultured buttermilk often found in stores, Amish buttermilk is traditionally made by allowing the cream to naturally separate and sour before churning. This process results in a thicker consistency and a more robust taste, making it perfect for baked goods and various other culinary creations.

Find a variety of Amish products at Presnell’s

In addition to our Amish butter and buttermilk, we also offer a wide range of other Amish products, including:

Amish Cheese: Discover the rich, creamy flavors of Amish cheese, sourced such as Sharp Cheddar, smooth Colby and so many more.  directly from Amish communities in Ohio’s Walnut Creek, a renowned Amish country.

Plenty of snacks from Walnut Creek: Indulge in a variety of delicious snacks by Walnut Creek Foods, directly from Ohio’s Amish communities in Walnut Creek.

And we have Amish peanut butter and fried pies too!

The Amish Way of Life

The Amish are renowned for their simple, community-oriented lifestyle, which extends to their approach to food production.

Living primarily in states like Pennsylvania, Ohio, Indiana, and Tennessee, Amish communities adhere to traditional methods passed down through generations. Their reliance on manual labor and natural processes results in exceptional-quality products.

Whether you’re spreading Amish butter on your morning toast, enjoying a slice of Amish cheese, or admiring a handmade quilt, you’re experiencing a tradition that has been carefully preserved through generations.

So, what are you waiting for? Come visit us at Presnell’s Produce and More. 

We’re proud to offer a variety of other locally sourced goods, in addition to our BEST local beef (not tooting our own horn here!). Our farm in Upper Crabtree has been raising high-quality cattle for over 25 years.

As always, we appreciate you shopping locally.